Skip to main content

VACANT PARLIAMENTARY SEATS CASE IN THE SUPREME COURT (DOWNLOAD FULL CASE IN PDF) ALEXANDER AFENYO MARKINS VRS SPEAKER OF PARLIAMENT

 


On the 12th day of November, 2024, the Supreme Court of Ghana by a majority decision of 5 -2, interpreted Article 97 (1) (g ) & (h) to the effect that a member of parliament who files nominations to contest elections on the ticket of a different political party other than the one for which he/she was elected as member of parliament, does loose his seat as a member of the current parliament. 

This decision has drawn sharp division in views of opinion leaders, lawyers, academics and jurists.  In order to understand the reasoning behind the opinions of the two sides of the bench, you are encouraged to read the full case which can be downloaded in this article.

 

WHO ARE THE JUSTICES 


Majority

Y. DARKO ASARE J.S.C

PG. SACKEY TORKONOO J.S.C (CJ), 

M. OWUSU J.S.C., 

Y. GAEWU J.S.C.  

S.K.A. ASIEDU J.S.C.


Minority (dissenting)

Tanko Amadu J.S.C. 

Lovelace -Johnson J.S.C

 

SUMMARY OF CASE

Four members of the 8th parliament of Ghana, one person from the National Democratic Congress (NDC) and three from the New Patriotic Party (NPP) majority side in parliament, were declared by the speaker of parliament to have vacated their seats. This is because three of them had filed nominations as independent candidates whilst one of them who is currently an independent MP for Fomena Constituency has now filed his nomination to contest as an NPP candidate for the constituency.

Before the Speaker made his declaration in Parliament, the Majority Leader, Alexaner Afenyo Markins filed a writ for the interpretation of Article 97 (1) (g) & (h) in the Supreme Court.

The said provision says as follows: A member of Parliament shall vacate his seat in Parliament, (g) if he leaves the party of which he was a member at the time of his election to Parliament to join another party or seeks to remain in Parliament as an independent member; or (h) if he was elected a member of Parliament as an independent candidate and joins a political party.

Based on this and other jurisprudential considerations, the Majority of the Supreme Court has held that a person who files his nomination to contest on a different political party's ticket for election into a future parliament (in this case the 9th parliament) cannot be said to have vacated his seat in the current parliament (the 8th parliament).

The Minority Justices have also disagreed. They have also argued amongst others, that the the right court to have handled this case was the high court and not the Supreme Court and that the high court could have started the case and remitted the interpretation aspect to the Supreme Court. They based their arguments on Article 99 (1) of the constitution which states as follows: "The High Court shall have jurisdiction to hear and determine any question whether - (a) a person has been validly elected as a member of Parliament or the seat of a member has become vacant".

Well, the Supreme Court has spoken and the decision of the majority is the LAW.

What do you think about this ruling of the Supreme Court. Let’s discuss your views in the comments section below.

You can read/ download the Full PDF version of the Judgment of the Supreme Court  by clinking this link. FULL JUDGMENT.

Kindly subscribe to this blog for updates whenever I post a new article. You can also follow or subscribe to my contents on the following social media channels so we have more interactions. FACEBOOK, TIKTOK, YOU TUBE.  

 

Yours Truly,

 

Richard Nii Amarh


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

MOTIVATION - MY ELEVEN YEARS JOURNEY TO THE BAR

    Somewhere in the first quarter of 2010, I received a call from Alexnder Osei Owusu (Lexis). I was then serving as a National Service person at the Akuapem Rural Bank in Mamfe – Akuapem. Lexis was my friend in council when we both served students in leadership positions at the University of Cape Coast.   I had discussed with him whilst we were yet to graduate, that I would like to study law after my first degree. He had seen a newspaper advert which was almost expiring so he called to prompt me. He said, Nii, tomorrow is the deadline for submission, have you submitted already and my answer was a no. I therefore had to quickly get permission from the office to go and buy the University of Ghana Admission forms and apply for the Post First Degree LLB. Everything was hand-written on physical forms and submitted physically at that time. I did not have my transcript at the time and it meant, I needed to travel to Cape Coast the next day, get the transcript and some reco...
4 comments
Read more

SEVEN MISTAKES TO AVOID WHEN APPLYING TO REGISTER A TRADE MARK IN GHANA.

  Ghana’s trademark regime is regulated by the Trade Mark Act of Ghana, 2004 (Act 664). Section 1 of this act defines trademark as “any sign or combination of sings capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one undertaking from the goods or services of other undertakings including words such as personal names, letters, numerals and figurative elements”.   A person who wants to exercise rights over a trademark in Ghana will have to register the said mark in Ghana under the law in order to be afforded the protections provided by the law. Several manufactures, traders, business and commercial entities find it cumbersome to overcome the challenges associated with the registration of trademark in Ghana. This writeup seeks to make clear the rules pertaining to the registration of trademarks in Ghana and specifically, the grounds that can lead to the rejection (refusal) of a trade mark registration application in Ghana.   Section 5 of the Trademarks Act has en...
Post a Comment
Read more

RAPE AND OTHER SEXUAL OFFENCES IN GHANA

    Whilst sex is a very important part of humanity, it also has calamitous consequences when it happens wrongly. This article is not intended to look at spiritual or medical consequences of sex but rather the legal consequences of sex when not done right in Ghana. So, in effect, I shall be taking you through some offences in Ghana which can be classified as sexual offences.     Rape seems to be the commonest sexual offence known by many people. But even so, there is a very widely accepted wrong impression, that rape is forceful or violent sex with a woman. This article will try to explain what rape really is, and its consequences. It shall also explore some other sexual offences such as Defilement, Carnal Knowledge, Indecent Assault, Unnatural Carnal Knowledge, Incest, Householder permitting Defilement of a child, Procuration, Seduction or Prostitution of a child under sixteen, and Compulsion of Marriage .   RAPE Rape is a very serious offence bec...
5 comments
Read more